Unemployment in Zimbabwe: Causes of unemployment in Zimbabwe and possible solution
Schiller International University
Professor Sharon Le Vavasseur
Causes of unemployment in Zimbabwe and possible solutions
“For every action there is a consequence” but the fact stands, an economy will always be at list 5% unemployment rate because of natural rate of unemployment, which is considered healthy for the economy. On the other hand the cyclical type of unemployment is the most dangerous type of unemployment an economy would want to experience because it is caused by recessions. Therefore, this paper aims at explaining the causes of unemployment in Zimbabwe and possible solutions that may be subscribed to assist the economy to work towards decreasing unemployment rate.
Background of Zimbabwe’s situation
To commence with, unemployment in Zimbabwe is defined as people over 16 years of age who are actively looking for a job, on the other hand it establishes subsistence farming as employment opposing the International Labour Organization’s view of unemployment statistics of Zimbabwe. Zimbabwe had being under the rule of Robert Mugabe for over 38 years since independence in 1980 and his party continues to rule after his dismissal. Zimbabwe was hit with economic sanctions after the land reform act in the 2000s by the U.S and Europe. The informal sector is the surviving sector with 70% to 90% of the population and the formal economy is shrinking as many companies have been shutting down. Also, for over a decade the current government and opposition party have been fighting tooth and nail at some instances causing political instability in the nation. According to the World Bank Zimbabwe’s unemployment is about 95% which is overall very high showing the rust in the economy’s engine.
Causes of unemployment
Firstly, poor governance and implementation of unappropriated policies has caused a negative multiplier effect in all sectors of the economy , in 2000 the Zimbabwean government enacted the Fast Land Reform Act that saw many white farmers being driven out of their farms that were flourishing and contributing heavily to the economy and thus led to Zimbabwe being the bread basket of Africa in that time , but the confiscation of land caused loss of jobs to farm workers and those in the export sector and the war veterans that took over the lands had no knowledge on how to manage commercial farms nor did they have capital to keep these farms running and this caused a huge loss in grains for the factories to be able to produce consumer products and also forcing the firms to lay off workers because of low productivity as people turned to importation of consumer goods and also, even forced some firms to shut down factories and thus lead to importation of grains and cost of production rose, ” For every action there is an equal and opposite reaction” (Newton), the prices for basic commodities rose leading to a cost push inflation.
Furthermore, in 2006 Zimbabwe suffered hyperinflation, most formal industries shut down moving most people to the informal sector, the Zimbabwean currency had lost tremendous value as the government kept printing huge sum of money supply misbalancing aggregate supply and demand as they were assisting in the war in DRC and the soldiers and army demanded high wages, devastating their own economy leading to an economic boom and bust and may people lost their jobs especially civil servants. In the government institutions corruption is very high that even the Transparency International has ranked Zimbabwe 157 /177 countries and mismanagement of funds is a huge barrier to any success of economic growth.
In 2016, USD$15 billion of government revenues from the mining sector went missing and no one has been accounted for it, huge balance of payments deficits to IMF and World Bank to settle in total $1.75 billion foreign debts this limits the government from having any money left to invest in infrastructure to try and resuscitate jobs for the locals, according to the world bank government spending was 2.05% of GDP and continued to increase all the way up to 2016. In 2008 unemployment rate was 5.43 and by 2010 it has risen to 6.26 according to the ILO , as the government also implemented the Indigenization and Empowerment Act as a discretional fiscal policy to help aid employment and empower the locals and generate revenue for the government as exports were very low, the act was propagated to make foreign companies offer at least 51% of their shares to Zimbabweans and this lead to many FDI firms to close firms and in return people employed by those private firms lost jobs and discouraged other potential investors like Aliko Dangotte.
Second, the Chinese Government has been investing in Zimbabwe after Zimbabwe propagated the Look East policy but still the Zimbabwean economy is still decimating because of bogus deals by the officials for example the Gwanda solar Farm , tender awarded to a Zimbabwean company Intertek that was in partnership with a Chinese firm for over 3 years no productivity has been done , the state parastatal transferred the official funds of USD$5 million to ground break the project , this was going to offer employment to over 1000 Zimbabweans but because state funds are mismanaged and no government follow up little has been down to account. the demographics have increased, the population has continued to increase at a rate of 2.35% yearly and there is no creation of new jobs and thus the new generation will not have formal jobs as the retirement age is high it will take years before a university graduate secures a job and giving a huge rise to frictional unemployment rate and also slows economic growth.
Furthermore, the geographical positioning of Zimbabwe being land locked already giving the sea accessed countries a comparative advantage on cost of raw materials and grains e.g. gas and maize because of less cost of transportation on foreign goods from other continents thus making Zimbabwe less competitive in the region and, less economic growth and increasing unemployment.
Additionally, education , despite the fact that Zimbabwe is ranked amongst the high literate African countries , as the world evolves and new technology is being invented because many graduates have been unemployed or rather never employed for years they have no update or retraining, the academic curriculum has not been revised effectively to match the worldly fast moving technological skills these new inventions of using software’s like block chain thus leading to a generation with a huge number of graduates , willing to work but with mismatched skills or no skills because what they learned back then it’s not what is required on the job anymore or new skills are required. In another circumstance mobile money transfers are rising as well as plastic money, most people don’t go to the banks anymore and for firms to have less expenses and more profits they lay off some bank tellers because of cash crisis and more online transactions contributes to increasing rate of structural unemployment because the tellers have no transferable skills.
First, the Finance Ministry and Reserve bank have to implement a new currency that is valuable for international trade and also decrease cash shortages after they have actually earned people’s trust so to discourage hoarding of currency giving incentive to investors to want to engage as the currency will hold value and security to help jump start the industries. Moreover, government institutions need to be reformed to create pure separation of power and all institutions are enforced to make sure there is transparency and accountability thus this will enable functioning of the economy and stimulate growth as investors will have trust in the agencies and when the government collects taxes they will create funds to reinvest in the economy by revising education curriculum and building of roads and schools to create jobs. Government should decrease its spending on the President, Ministers and other parastatal seniors because these funds can be redirected to the growth of the economy than buy luxurious cars and real estate for institution officials.
Also, Zimbabwe has to look towards regulating the informal sector as it will contribute more to the government revenues as over 70% of the people are involved in informal business. The mining sector should have agencies that will make sure their strategic plans for the revenues generated from the main mineral resources the country, diamond and platinum, the funds should be redistributed to other sectors to ensure stability and function thus creating jobs as well the minerals are scarce when they deplete the economy will not crush like it’s been hit with a Dutch disease because it will still have other industrial sectors to rely on to keep the economy running. Some of the parastatals like Air Zimbabwe must be privatized as they have been bed ridden by bogus CEOs and executives that divert funds into their pockets and practice serious nepotism and employ uneducated people into positions that they have no qualifications.
On top of that when foreign firms invest in the country the government should also have strict rules if there to lower their cooperate tax they must employ at list a certain number of workers from the locals because as the situation states most foreign companies especially those in Chiyadzwa diamond mines and the Hwange electric plant not many Zimbabweans are employed because of lack of knowledge and if vocational schools are to be enacted by the government to teach Chinese and some of the skills needed in engineering despite educational level the unemployment rate would decrease
To sum it up all, as Ellen Wilkinson said, “Unemployment is bigger than a political party. It is a national scandal”, Zimbabwe as suffered devastating rates of unemployment, inconsistency and mismanagement of both monetary and fiscal policies implemented by the Zimbabwean government has caused great destabilization of economic growth and in turn the unemployment rate increased. Political turmoil and unfriendly international relations with the west especially have also left Zimbabwe with less power countries to assist revamp its economy. The solutions are on the table but it will take the Zimbabwean people as well as those in power to choose if they want change as one rule party has been in power and no change has been seen for over 39 years and unemployment keeps increasing.
Knight, J. Jenkin, C (2001, Dec). The Decline of Zimbabwe. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
Simpson, M. Hawkins, T (2018). The Primacy of Regime Survival: State Fragility and Economic Destruction in Zimbabwe (Chapter 9).Springer.
Nordhaus,S (2005). Macroeconomics (Chapter 15, pg 311-316. New York: Mcgraw-Hill
World Bank. Unemployment rate Zimbabwe. Retrieved from https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SL.UEM.TOTL.ZS
The Global Economy. Zimbabwe Economic Growth Data Chart. Retrieved from https://www.theglobaleconomy.com/Zimbabwe/Economic_growth/
BBC ( 2017, Dec). Are 90% of Zimbabweans are employed. The Reality Check Team. Retrieved from https://www.bbc.com/news/business-42116932